Help us to Keep The Lights On for another decade! Back the Cable
The Bristol Cable

What future for a gentrified Bristol?

Faced with rising inequality, gentrification and a world gone mad, where will Bristol go?

City

Faced with rising inequality, gentrification and a world gone mad, where will Bristol go?

Illustration: www.zoe-power.com

Modern cities face an almost impossible conundrum, which is playing out in metropolises across the Western world. At their best, they are culturally thriving, socially diverse places, open to newcomers, and possessed of their own maverick spirit – something that, in recent memory, has been true of everywhere from Berlin and Manchester, to New York and Barcelona. But when word gets out and the wider world wants a piece of the action, success can very quickly curdle into something much more problematic. We all know the basic script: property places inflate, people get driven out, and before long, yesterday’s atmosphere of creativity and diversity becomes today’s climate of elitism and exclusion. Large swathes of London now fit that picture, as does pretty much the whole of Manhattan; across Europe and beyond, people in countless cities fear that where they live will soon go the same way.

This is the basic juncture at which Bristol finds itself. With London overheating, it is now considered a prime place for people and companies to relocate, and as a result, the city is changing fast. Neighbourhoods like Easton, St Paul’s and Montpelier increasingly offer case-studies in gentrification, while controversies regularly flare up: the fuss kicked up about the redevelopment of the Carriageworks in Stokes Croft; similar disaffection elsewhere about the paltry share of new housing given over to “affordable” homes. All over Bristol, there is a palpable sense of rising inequality being the city’s single biggest issue. And clearly, this is not something abstract and theoretical. Inequality is a matter of the single mother in Lawrence Hill who thinks that Clifton is another world; the community volunteer in St Paul’s who fears that new arrivals have no inclination to get involved in what she does; the young people being pushed further and further out by ever-increasing rents.www.zoe-power.com

You can tell that these are the issues at the heart of the city’s present and future from the fact that both main contenders in the looming mayoral elections endlessly talk about them. Labour’s Marvin Rees warns of the danger of “a fragile society and loose social ties that leave you vulnerable to the type of social disintegration we saw ending in the 2011 summer riots.” The sitting mayor, George Ferguson, insists that “during my first term we have worked tirelessly to address inequality in this city”, and accepts that even if the city is successful on paper, “not everyone in Bristol participates in this.” Take out the miserable issue of parking, and these concerns define the contest.

This is a good thing, obviously. It’s some tribute to Bristol’s innate sense of fairness that its politics has taken this turn, and it means that the mayoral contest actually represents a rare political chance to talk about something meaningful. But the post of mayor actually offers precious few instruments that can be used to grapple with the problems at the core of the city’s politics. Of course, much more social housing would be a start; insisting the city’s employers offer decent wages and conditions would be another step forward. But even the distant promise of some kind of combined authority for Bristol and its wider area might offer no convincing progress: Manchester is leading the way in that field, and there is rising concern that its new power structures might amount to the same old austerity and inequality being overseen in a slightly different way. The truth is that much bigger forces are at work, and Bristol’s fate remains in the hands of the Westminster politicians still pursuing chronically regressive, backward-looking policies – while they themselves are in thrall to an economic model spinning out of control, over the world.

In the end, what really counts in the fight against inequality isn’t this or that election, but an active citizenry, a vibrant local media, and a sense that a city has a clear understanding of what makes it work, and the collective will to try and hold on to it. On all those fronts, Bristol is better placed than a lot of other cities: that’s why so many of us love the place. But in the next ten years, we’ll find out if Bristolians can collectively work out how to blaze a trail away from inequality and exclusion, or whether their city will succumb to the opposite fate: becoming yet another place where creativity and openness have withered away, and all you can hear is the deafening roar of money. No pressure, then….

Join 2,500 Cable members redefining local media

Your support will help the Cable grow, deepening our connections in the city and investigating the issues that matter most in our communities.

Join now

What makes us different?

Comments

Report a comment. Comments are moderated according to our Comment Policy.

  • Fantastic writing. To the point. Realistic. We better hope, for Bristol s indentity seem to be resilient and unique. Unfortunately we accept quietly the fact that “the deafening sounds of money” is some form of a greater power. Human willingness should be stronger thou. To thrive for a better and equal place. The act of voting is only a minor step to the bigger picture change.

    Reply

  • You’ve hit the nail on the head about the ‘newcomers’. I’m in St Werburghs and have been for 25yrs (its all we could afford 25yrs ago). Over the last 5 years the people moving in (who can afford a £300k terrace house) not only are completely disinterested in the existing populus but seem to be obsessed with pushing the last few Bristolians out of the area. Every week I get another knock on the door with a petition to close the local pub (its a bit noisy sometimes) move on the traveller’s, move on our local ‘problem’ family (who I actually quite like), moaning about parking (even though they all seem to own a big car each) complaining about unkempt front gardens, etc, etc. All of this seems to enabled by our local trustafarian Green Party Councillors. I’ve sort of had enough all my friends have moved on my kids could never afford to live round here and some 20 something hipster will be happy enough to give me £350k for my house. In 10 years St Werburghs will just be another Islington and completely devoid of any ‘localism’.

    Reply

    • Im in Easton and feel the same. Been around here 22 years.. Bought my house about 13 years ago.. The new lott are just not cool.. what gets me is the way they look at me like i shouldn’t be here.. Like im invading their patch??.. Ive lived in Bristol since i was 15..Im an artist..know allot of the old school people/ ravers/artists..low key local celebs.. like yourself most probably.. but these new guys in the last 5/6 years talk down to me like im a piece of s***..so many of them are from the home counties and outer london suburbs (Although they usually say London like us Carrot crunchers wouldn’t know the difference).. when i moved here as a kid we interacted with the status quo.. we respected the Jamaican community and Asian community..the people that were here already..We wanted to fit in not to take over.. communities change yes but what gets me is the downright arrogance and disrespect of some of the new lott..They act Like they created Bristol..?? Like they know something i don’t.. They bring nothing to the table.. Not cool.. Not funny.. Not interactive or creative.. They’re just bland arrogant and have money oh and they love Banksey.. But they want nothing to do with the subculture that made Banksey… As a low income artist i have no f***ing idea where im meant to go now..These clueless f**utts are sucking the life out this area… (Only thing that makes me laugh is they keep getting broke into and complaining about dog shit..cause they really have no idea where they just moved too)

      Reply

  • @ Paul. Did any of your friends refuse the ridiculously over-inflated valuation of their property when they sold out ?

    Reply

  • @Richard, what would be the point of that?

    Reply

Post a comment

Mark if this comment is from the author of the article

By posting a comment you agree to our Comment Policy.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related content

‘This is long overdue’: campaigning high-rise residents promised action to improve their homes

After years of living in crumbling, leaking housing, and putting pressure on the council to take action, people in neglected blocks of flats at St Jude's hope change is finally coming.

‘Prison felt safer than the streets’: why women’s homelessness needs to be better understood

From rough sleeping to overstretched waiting lists for a social home, women in Bristol and beyond are disproportionately affected by the housing crisis – but their needs are often not recognised.

Revealed: Building owner ‘abandons’ leaseholders trapped in unsafe Brislington flats

Orchard House residents took matters into their own hands to force the building owner to carry out remediation works, under powers brought in after the Grenfell tragedy. But as the legal deadline nears, little progress has been made.

Inclusive or exclusive: can community-led housing schemes provide for people most in need?

In recent years Bristol has seen the development of several new community-led housing schemes, which are often driven by small resident groups – but also aim to house people in need of a social home. How is the model working out – and with funds shrinking, does it have a future?

Bristol rogue landlord rented out room despite banning order, tenants say

Naomi Knapp was prohibited from renting out her properties to new tenants in 2022, but the Cable has uncovered evidence to suggest she brought in new tenants anyway.

‘I can do action’: cafe owner who organised tower block evacuation response aiming to be councillor

When she heard Barton House was being evacuated in November, Cafe Conscious owner Deniece Dixon got to work helping families who had become homeless. Two months on, she explains why she’s set her sights on City Hall

Join our newsletter

Get the essential stories you won’t find anywhere else

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter to get our weekly round-up direct to your inbox every Saturday

Join our newsletter

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter

Get our latest stories & essential Bristol news
sent to your inbox every Saturday morning