Help us reach our campaign target: Become a member
The Bristol Cable

Notes from City Hall: Four hours in purgatory


Our intrepid council correspondent, Sid Ryan, sits through the first meeting of the Marvin Rees administration so you don’t have to.

It’s a new dawn in Bristol. A red one. For the new Labour administration, the board is set and the players are making their opening moves. And for me, as your self-appointed city hall commentator, I’ll be sitting on the sidelines trying to separate the truth from the spin and work out what the grand strategy is. That, and making a lot of bad one-liners.

This week the main event was the Full Council meeting, the first since the elections. It’s hard not to be a little impressed going to these things, if only for the setting. The town hall is huge. You could fit the House of Commons in twice over easily and it’s pretty much the same layout, all plush carpets, gilt moulding, polished wood and red leather.

You’ve got to appreciate the fine democratic tradition of honest local people standing up to represent their community and trying to make Bristol a better place. The earnest speeches about improving our common lot, building the world we need to see. The reverence to the artifacts of power, the swords, rods, robes, and special hats. It was making me a little misty-eyed. Or maybe I was moved to tears of boredom?

To reiterate the title: Four. Effing. Hours. That right there is the basic dynamic of the council. It’s all very important, but my god is it dull.

To be perfectly fair, if I was looking for excitement I picked the wrong day to start – the first meeting of the council is pretty much all procedure. First on the agenda was getting in the new Lord Mayor – not to be confused with the mayor elect, Marvin Rees – and getting rid of the old one. Lord Mayor is a ceremonial position and the mayor-ing process is basically a lot of speeches of thanks.

“It was making me a little misty-eyed… Or maybe that was tears of boredom.”

There was an adorable exchange between Jeff Lovell (L) the incoming Lord Mayor and ‘very proud lad from the South of the City’ and ‘Jacko’, that’s Councillor Chris Jackson (L) to you and me. Cllr Jackson gave a lovely speech to his friend and colleague, and, on getting some thanks in return from Lovell, he threw out a chirpy, Bristolian-accented ‘Cheers, mate!’.

Council is nice like that. They go nuts for the rules and procedures, but they’re all normal people and no-one is going to get too annoyed about a joke here and there or Cllr Mark Weston going off on a weird tangent about the political insights that can strike while doing a little pressure washing with a cider in-hand, which he did.

But then you also have quite touching moments, Cllr Asher Craig (L) gave tribute to her friend and mentor, Miss Carmen Beckford, one of the ‘seven saints of St Pauls’ and elder stateswoman of Bristol who passed away last month. Or when Cllr Cleo Lake (G) took the time to read a poem and bring a little life to the Chamber.

There was even a mini-drama. In the half-way break a kerfuffle broke out. Paul Saville, who you might remember from the Mayoral ballot papers, got escorted out of the hall by security. He says he wasn’t doing anything offensive, just chatting to some of the members about housing and the Avonmouth eviction, but the security guards were a little worried about him eating the councillors’ sandwiches.

It could have ended there, but Mayor Rees and Cabinet Member for Homes, Paul Smith (L), popped outside to give him some face-time and calm things down. I’m not sure the administration are scared enough of Mr Saville and friends for the fracas to have a real impact, but in the end he got what he wanted –  the Avonmouth occupiers didn’t get evicted

The main event was a speech from Marvin Rees and the replies from other party leaders. Most of it we’d heard before, but it’s well presented. He likes to grip and push down on the edge of the lectern, a neat trick to get that shoulders-back, chest-out effect. Kudos to his media-trainer, but what makes it work is that when he talks, he seems like he means it.

The plan appears to be to release a review of council finances next week, and then to work out what to do within that envelope. We’ll have to see if the ambitions from the campaign trail translate into feasible, funded programmes.

There are a couple of specifics though: A recycling centre on Hartcliffe way, the residents parking zones and 20mph speed limits are going to be reviewed ward by ward, a price freeze on parking licenses too. There will be a Bristol Charter for Corporate Social Responsibility (whatever that’ll look like), a drive to get Bristol employers to pay a living wage and the first Mayoral commission is going to look at the gender and race pay-gap. Oh, and houses, houses and more houses.

The word of the day was collaboration. Hard to tell where the strategy comes in here, whether it’s an ideological break from the previous Mayor, George Ferguson, a little pre-emptive blame sharing should things not go as plan, or maybe it’s totally genuine? Obviously this spiel went down well with the other parties. They could have spent another five years out in the wilderness, doing a lot of shouting but getting nowhere near the levers of power.

“The Greens are giving notice that they’ll not hesitate to give Marvin a kicking if, or maybe when, he fails to deliver on his promises.”

To try and sum up everyone’s position on the new administration: the Conservatives want rail, road and respect, and seem happy to cut a few deals to get them. They’ve got a lot of power over the administration through the committee structures anyway, so it’s not like they’ll struggle to get most of their agenda through.

The Greens were more reserved, the general tone being: “We wish you luck, and I think you’re going to need it.” The main worry is housing. Turns out that the Government have made life quite difficult for councils wanting to build affordable homes. The Greens are giving notice that they’ll not hesitate to give Marvin a kicking if, or maybe when, he fails to deliver on his promises. A little payback for Labour seizing housing as their political territory and smashing the Greens apart with it during the election.

As for the Lib Dems, they seemed pretty happy. They mentioned a few specifics, libraries, recycling and the Bristol Arena, and the upcoming metro-mayor referendum. The greater concern than what the council is doing is how it’s doing it. The Lib Dems just want to be kept in the loop and be able to raise concerns without being accused of playing politics.

After three and a half hours of speeches the energy of the room was at its lowest. Councillors’ discipline had been good so far, but there was a lot more fiddling around on their regulation iPads. Not that I’m blameless on that issue either.

A bit of a shame, because the Youth Council presented their manifesto towards the end and it was actually quite practical and quietly radical. It got taken seriously by the Mayor at least, not that surprising considering that the chairperson, Sophie Giltinan, was more eloquent than most of the ‘real’ councillors.

The final business of the day were a few procedural changes to the constitution. I thought I might be onto a scorcher, noticing that they’re removing the power for any two members of a scrutiny committee to call for a review, leaving the decision solely in the hands of the chairperson or the civil servant responsible – but no-one I talked to seemed bothered by it. So it’s either not a power-grab, or just a very secret one!

Then, all of a sudden, with an ‘aye’, ‘aye’, ‘aye’, and all the Scrutiny Committee chairs were appointed. The Conservatives get the big one, Oversight and Scrutiny, and the ‘Business Change and Resources’ committee. Greens get ‘Place’, Lib Dems get ‘Neighbourhoods’ and Labour get ‘People’. More on that when we work out exactly what the Committees are going to be doing…


And that was that. All finished. Thank god.


Report a comment. Comments are moderated according to our Comment Policy.

  • Well you clearly haven’t been to many City Council meetings! This one, was always going to be procedural and pretty boring for anyone not really involved. But it all had to happen. We went to many meetings in the past regime as we had issues to talk about….and we loved watching the now forgotten ex mayor entertain us all by losing his rag and attacking all and sundry. Meetings probably wont’ be so much fun any more….but there will be a lot more accomplished. The Greens can’t really pull much weight…as their surge is very over…and everyone else wants to just get on with it now. They might consider eating fewer lemons. Change for the good can be just a bit less sensational for the press and a lot less fun to watch….but maybe this is a good thing if something is actually happening in all those neglected parts of Bristol who have never really had a voice until now. Reese does sound as if he means what he says, and he has thought it though ( he has had some time!) and made some plans plus got good people in to realize them. Patience might be a virtue just now….I know…unfashionable.


  • I actually totally agree! I don’t *really* think it’s all that dull, just being sarcastic. I actually find it all very interesting, even this procedural stuff. I’m just looking forward to when there are some policies to discuss.


  • Well Done Sid. These things are like crossing the Sahara with little or no water.


  • My thanks to Sid Ryan for his excellent reporting.


  • Sid. Just concerned that easy sarcasm will contribute to the distancing of people from politics. It might make people smile a bit but have you ever thought through the political climate you contribute to? If you continue to do sneary commentary, you may inadvertently deter new people from participating, making change less likely in the thing you criticise and I would suspect want to be different. I am not saying not to do what you do or not to do political journalism. I am just suggesting the prioritisation of insight and intelligence rather than sarcasm because bad political journalism doesn’t help anyone and damages the credibility of the publisher – and for many the Cable has offered a slither of hope for Bristol media. But that’s just my view. I leave you to it.


Post a comment

Mark if this comment is from the author of the article

By posting a comment you agree to our Comment Policy.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related content

Analysis: It’s time for politicians to come together on mass transit

A leaked report has concluded that underground sections are needed and achievable in Bristol’s future mass transit system. As we move to the next stage in the process, we need our politicians to work together.

Row over shopping centre demolition decision grinds on after government walks away from intervening

Council planning lawyer argues decision to refuse proposed redevelopment of Broadwalk Centre in Knowle in May did not rule out this being reversed – as happened a few weeks later.

Bristol City Council slapped with warning over poor performance on freedom of information requests

The local authority has been criticised for years over its failure to responding to FOI requests within 20-day timescales.

Trams, or an underground? As Bristol weighs its public transport options, can it learn from across the Channel?

Bristol is notorious for its congestion and poor public transport, and has been hit by a worsening bus crisis. As it looks to a new mass transit system to solve its problems, cities such as Rennes and Bordeaux can offer valuable lessons.

How local ‘health hubs’ could encourage more women to get checked for breast cancer

Bristol breast cancer rates are 16% higher than the national average, and women from deprived areas are less likely to attend appointments. We asked women about the impact better community-based services could make.

Bristol’s flood defences are being pushed to their limit. What is the city’s long-term plan, and will it be enough?

The council is searching for an extra £100 million to fund future flood defences to protect low-lying areas of the city. While residents call for greater action, the Cable looks across the North Sea to Rotterdam for inspiration.

Join our newsletter

Get the essential stories you won’t find anywhere else

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter to get our weekly round-up direct to your inbox every Saturday

Join our newsletter

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter

Get our latest stories & essential Bristol news
sent to your inbox every Saturday morning