Help us to Keep The Lights On for another decade! Back the Cable
The Bristol Cable

Do Bristol schools pass the admissions test?

Local authority oversight raises questions about equality of access to education

Edition 8

Local authority oversight raises questions about equality of access to education
Words & Photo: Alec Saelens

The question of equal access to education in Bristol arose to varying degrees on the recent mayoral campaign trails. While Christine Townsend put herself forward as the candidate dedicated to raising the profile of issues within Bristol’s school system, the process of admissions also featured as a manifesto priority of Marvin Rees, who said: “To tackle educational inequality, children from lower socio-economic backgrounds must have the same choices as those from wealthier parents.”

For most parents, finding a school for their child is bewildering, so understanding unlawful obstacles to schools admissions – let alone reporting them – is not a familiar exercise. The purpose of admissions regulations is about facilitating parents or carers’ access to preferred schools, and having a clear and non-discriminatory selection criteria.

08-admissions-1The Office for Schools Adjudicators (OSA) is the governmental body ultimately responsible for reviewing schools’ admission processes and requesting legally binding changes. However, it does not begin new investigations and depends entirely on referrals from organisations, members of the public and the local authority.

The type of objections raised include: faith-based selection, holding interviews for prospective pupils, testing ability rather than aptitude (capacity to learn), requesting unnecessary personal identity and family information, and unclear information about the catchment area.

In Bristol, the OSA has investigated nine schools since 2014 and upheld, at least partially, the objections made against the school’s admissions process. For example, the Merchants’ Academy in Withywood was found responsible for 11 breaches of the Schools Admissions Code, but refused to comment on the subsequent changes made.

Of these OSA investigations four were based on objections by a member of the public and three put forward by the Fair Admissions Campaign (FAC), begging the question – what is the local authority up to?

Can’t trust the Trust?

Oversight and accountability mechanisms are dwindling as schools change status. As most schools are now academies, the local authority’s role in scrutinising admission processes has been passed on to the governing bodies of individual schools or school chains – the academy trusts. Professor Anne West, from the London School of Economics’ Education Research Group, has said: “the fact that admissions decisions are carried out at school level is problematic: it is not possible to know what goes on ‘behind closed doors’.”

None of the previous objections submitted to the OSA were from the local authority. In the last year, four schools failed to make their admissions arrangements available. Meanwhile, in its annual report to the OSA, the council declared itself ‘confident’ that admissions policies and procedures of schools were lawful.

Bristol council is “turning a blind eye.”

Paul Jacobs, service director for education and skills at the council, said “where issues arise [we] will challenge schools on admissions practice and support parents as appropriate.” However, addressing the lack of reviews, Christine Townsend, who sits on a region’s admissions appeal board, claimed that Bristol council is “turning a blind eye.”

The criteria for challenging the admissions process have recently been threatened by the education secretary, Nicky Morgan, wishing to prohibit faith-related objections to admissions practices. This was met by criticism from Lord Watson, Labour, who claimed that “the level of segregation of pupils by faith – and thus often by ethnicity – and by socio-economic position is dangerously high.”

Have you got problems with school admissions in Bristol? Get in touch with the Cable.

Join 2,500 Cable members redefining local media

Your support will help the Cable grow, deepening our connections in the city and investigating the issues that matter most in our communities.

Join now

What makes us different?

Comments

Post a comment

Mark if this comment is from the author of the article

By posting a comment you agree to our Comment Policy.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related content

How a media backlash led to a St Paul’s woman’s dramatic release from prison

In 1933 Mary Burridge, a poor mother of five, was sentenced to a month’s hard labour after stealing a few items of food at Easter. But after a national outcry over her treatment, a wealthy lawyer flew to Cardiff to free her from prison.

Whistleblowers reveal institutional racism at local NHS trust

A Cable investigation spanning months has uncovered that complaints of institutional racism at University Hospitals Bristol and Weston NHS Trust went unheard, despite promises from management to tackle the issue.

Cities of the future must prioritise the health of people and the planet

Preventing ill-health from poor-quality urban environments, and promoting fairness, are at the heart of a project Bristol is helping to lead.

Rising demand and falling donations causing shortages at Bristol food banks

The cost of living crisis means more people need food banks – but fewer are donating. The Cable spoke to organisations across the city trying to help the growing number of households who can't afford to eat.

Julz Davis: checking in on Martin Luther King’s dream

Campaigner Julz Davis speaks to the Cable about his Race for Power project to improve racial equity in Bristol, the UK's seventh most unequal city.

Cooking up a storm: The project tackling Bristol’s rising food poverty

The Mazi Project provides pre-portioned meal kits to marginalised young people to address food poverty in the city.

Join our newsletter

Get the essential stories you won’t find anywhere else

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter to get our weekly round-up direct to your inbox every Saturday

Join our newsletter

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter

Get our latest stories & essential Bristol news
sent to your inbox every Saturday morning