Our journalism needs your support! Become a member
The Bristol Cable

Breaking: Councillors vote to defer Choc Factory development but fight continues.

City

Partial victory but more affordable housing not guaranteed

Councillors have voted by 8-2 to defer the decision on the controversial Chocolate Factory development primarily on the basis of affordable housing, despite a last ditch offer of 4.4% affordable units from the developer, and a recommendation to approve by planning officers.

The cross party committee also raised and heard various concerns ranging from the protected presence of bats, traffic implications and the “non-provision of parking”. The vote follows Cable revelations about the developer’s profit calculations, tax affairs and mounting community pressure from groups like ACORN. 

What will happen next is uncertain.The developer, Generator Group, could make amendments to its application that could satisfy concerns. One possibility touted by committee members would be to demolish the existing structures and build anew. This could reduce build costs, improve the profits of the developer and therefore the levels of affordable housing.

“They clearly haven’t consulted the community properly on this” said Nick Ballard from campaign group ACORN, adding “we’re pleased that councillors recognised this along with other issues and voted to not approve the application today. We now expect Generator Group to fully open negotiations as we move forward.”

However, the developer could appeal the deferral. In this case the odds could be heavily stacked against the council, as the appeal would be heard by the Planning Inspectorate. The Inspectorate, an executive agency of the government, is bound to abide by strict national planning laws, aspects of which a council planning officer today described as like being “sent into the boxing ring with one arm tied behind your back”. The council could also be required to pay all costs of the appeal.

This scenario appeared to be troubling many councillors on the committee. One expressed concern that frustration from some of the community was being directed at them as local representatives, rather than the Conservative government and their policies.

The strength of feeling regarding the matter was clear from dozens in the public gallery, which included Easton councillors Ruth Pickersgill and Afzal Shah, as well from the councillors on the committee. One councillor claimed that the present application amounted to the developer saying, “Screw you Bristol, we’re not giving you the housing you need”.

Stay tuned for updates.

Comments

Report a comment. Comments are moderated according to our Comment Policy.

Post a comment

Mark if this comment is from the author of the article

By posting a comment you agree to our Comment Policy.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related content

From city of sanctuary to ‘city of opportunity’ – how Bristol can better integrate refugees

Asylum seekers and refugees should be thought of as ‘citizens-in-waiting’, people with rights, skills and potential, a new report argues. Instead, many people at the sharp end of the system feel shut out of contributing to society.

How the Help to Buy scheme became a massive hindrance to my family moving house

Government loans promised an affordable path onto the housing ladder. But for some they have only deferred unmanageable debt, and a change in the firm administering Help to Buy has set off a nightmare for people trying to move.

No fault evictions on the rise in Bristol amid calls for renting reforms to be strengthened

The Renters Reform Bill, which is slowly going through parliament, doesn’t tackle the affordability crisis and could allow no fault evictions to continue, say campaigners.

Revealed: Renters living in mouldy flats handed steep rent hike by millionaire London landlords

Residents of the iconic Queens Court housing block in Clifton are fed up with living in poor conditions and their complaints being ignored, a Cable investigation has uncovered.

South Bristol shopping centre will be knocked down after planning councillors’ shock U-turn

Opposition councillors slammed a decision to redevelop the Broadwalk Shopping Centre after a developer said it could deliver extra affordable homes there – although no promises were made.

Service cuts, redundancies and rising caseloads: St. Mungo’s staff vote for indefinite strike action

Unite members from St.Mungo’s vote to escalate their month-long strike to indefinitely, after charity refuses to meet pay demands

Join our newsletter

Get the essential stories you won’t find anywhere else

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter to get our weekly round-up direct to your inbox every Saturday

Join our newsletter

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter

Get our latest stories & essential Bristol news
sent to your inbox every Saturday morning