Help us reach our campaign target: Become a member
The Bristol Cable

Do you want advertising in your parks?


Anti-advertising campaigners warn that introducing advertising into Bristol’s green spaces could detract from the wellbeing they provide.

There is growing evidence to support what we all already know about parks: they’re good for us. With Bristol’s mental health services at crisis point, free spaces like parks have a proven positive effect on well being and are now more important than ever.

According to one US study, people living in greener urban areas were, on average, happier than people living in places with less greenery around. Parks may be about to become a whole lot busier though, as Bristol City Council (BCC) eyes them up as places for profit, not only calm. After encountering fierce opposition – more than 4,400 signed a ‘Protect Our Parks’ petition – BCC backtracked on its initial plan to make parks become cost neutral. However as it stands, our parks will still lose £2.86m a year from 2019 as the council tries to close the £108m budget gap. The council says that services will need to be “run in a very different way, working in partnership with communities to look at income generation opportunities, while also making savings and making services as efficient as possible”.

Being put in the position of being a consumer in a place where we’re trying to find relaxation and escape from all of that doesn’t seem right at all

BCC has considered a number of different potential earners for parks in the the consultation, which is open to the public until Monday, January 29th. Suggestions include, hosting more events, introducing paid-for activities and bringing in more cafes. Whatever option the council goes with, it’s likely to make big changes to how parks feel. But the proposal that has got people talking is the possibility of rolling out  advertising in parks, which the council say would bring in at least £50,000 a year.

“It feels like a very extreme step to take, to introduce advertising,” says Nicola Round, co-founder of anti-advertising campaign group Adblock Bristol.

“While we do understand that there are funding issues in the council, is it really, ‘any way we can find money we’ll take it?’”

“Parks are places for leisure, places to nurture our well being, they’re places where we go to escape the stresses of modern living,” says Round. “Introducing advertising which is designed to make us feel inadequate and stressed out in order to make us buy completely contradicts that.”

Councils don’t have a statutory duty to maintain parks so arguably it’s logical that they’ll be among the first services to feel the squeeze of the cuts. However Melinda Green, a writer and member of Friends of Eastville Park, insists that advertising is not the answer.

“I think parks are places for relaxation, rest, peace and de-stressing. Advertising has huge influence on people, even if you’re just walking by.

“I find my inspiration in open green spaces. It’s vital to creativity.”

Meanwhile, Round says that she is concerned that allowing advertising in our green spaces could reduce the positive impact that parks have on wellbeing.

“Advertising exists to make us buy stuff. It uses messages that make us feel inadequate in order to make us spend.”

“Being put in the position of being a consumer in a place where we’re trying to find relaxation and escape from all of that doesn’t seem right at all.”

“Appropriate advertising”

The council consultation says that the advertising would be “appropriate” and that the move wouldn’t allow advertising for tobacco, alcohol, e-cigarettes, religions or political parties or pay-day loans, or any content contravening the council’s equalities policies or seeming to offer escort or sexual services.

But this list of prohibited content doesn’t include a lot of advertising that some argue is detrimental to people’s well being and mental health.

Round says that there is a particular concern around children and fast food advertising. Research suggests that children are particularly susceptible to advertising, with children under seven less able to recognise the “persuasive intent of commercial appeals”.

“Children see thousands of advertising messages every day and we have a problem with childhood obesity in Bristol. Do we really want to be exposing our children to adverts exposing them to these unsustainable lifestyles with junk food?” she asks.

Rob Acton-Campbell, Secretary of Bristol Parks Forum, says that all the suggested ways of generating revenue would be ok, “provided it’s not too much and people still have a place to go”.

“We don’t want the place full of advertising billboards, but I’m sure that’s not what they’re planning,” he said. “There needs to be an agreement as to what extent there will be advertising.”

A Bristol City Council spokesperson said: “The current Parks consultation will help the council decide whether advertising in parks is an option it wishes to go ahead with and if so, it will help define in more detail what advertising is appropriate. A report should be published online within three to four weeks of the consultation closing.”



Report a comment. Comments are moderated according to our Comment Policy.

Post a comment

Mark if this comment is from the author of the article

By posting a comment you agree to our Comment Policy.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related content

Healing is a justice issue: how can we radicalise the voluntary sector, amid a perfect storm of cuts?

When it comes to recovery from trauma, meeting people’s basic needs such as food, shelter, and physical safety is not enough. In an increasingly harsh environment, charities will need all their imagination and creativity to do more.

The gloves are on: the boxing charity helping young people bounce back

Photo essay: Empire Fighting Chance equips some of Bristol’s most marginalised young people with tools for survival and success

When words fail: Meet the Bristol group nurturing male musicians’ mental health

The Seed Sessions project combines counselling and music mentoring to help young men express themselves. We heard from its founder, one of the participants and a counsellor working with the group about the power of music as a therapeutic tool.

How talking clubs are getting Bristol blokes to open up and be vulnerable

I joined Talk Club and learned I can’t regulate my emotions. Then I got schooled by a therapist on toxic masculinity and dangerous role models. But how are you doing, out of 10?

Lost opportunities: are inquests failing to prevent future deaths?

Jess Durdy’s death followed clear failings by those charged with caring for her, her mother believes, but a coroner didn’t see it that way. Bereaved families, campaigners and lawyers say an opaque, inconsistent system needs change.

‘I was finally diagnosed with ADHD at 25. Would I have got this sooner if I was a boy?’

After years of being misdiagnosed and incorrectly medicated, Dolores has finally got an ADHD diagnosis. But how different could her childhood have been if she’d been diagnosed sooner, like boys often are?

Join our newsletter

Get the essential stories you won’t find anywhere else

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter to get our weekly round-up direct to your inbox every Saturday

Join our newsletter

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter

Get our latest stories & essential Bristol news
sent to your inbox every Saturday morning