Help us keep the lights on Support us
The Bristol Cable

Transforming mental health provision in schools?

Therapists and educators criticise the government’s proposed changes to how mental health services are delivered.

Reports

Therapists and educators criticise the government’s proposed changes to how mental health services are delivered.

Photo: Off the Record (Bristol)

Children’s mental health charity Place2Be launched the annual Children’s Mental Health Week in 2015 to raise awareness of young people’s emotional wellbeing. This year’s week, running 5-11 February, takes place against a backdrop of depleted mental health services nationwide, with therapists struggling with overwhelming case loads.

Could the government’s green paper on ‘Transforming children and young people’s mental health provision’, released December last year, improve the situation? Medical and education professionals across the city have warned that the new plans may not amount to much more than spreading existing resources even thinner.

The plans put schools at the heart of identifying and intervening with children with mental health needs. Proposals include having a designated mental health ‘lead’ in all schools and colleges by 2025, introducing mental health support teams to provide a link between the NHS and schools, and to shorten waiting times for children waiting for treatment to four weeks – less in urgent cases.

“Paying lip service rather than investing”

Therapists and teachers have welcomed the idea of a ‘joined-up’ approach, and the potential that the changes could reduce stigma around mental health issues. However, there’s no indication that there will be any extra funding to support the extra responsibilities expected of services that are already under-resourced – Bristol’s child and adolescent mental health services (CAMHS) is among the worst-funded in the country.

“Without the money, they’re just paying lip service to the needs rather than actually investing in dealing with it,” said Jamie Barry, headteacher of Parson Street Primary School. He points out that the school has had to implement cuts which affected wellbeing services. Parson Street has lost learning mentors and family support workers to budget cuts.

“The workforce in CAMHS is wholly inadequate for the numbers of children needing support”

The school still has its ‘Every Child Matters’ team – though working on reduced hours – to help support children’s emotional and social needs, but the waiting list to use the therapy services “is just astronomical,” said Barry. “I’m struggling to see that it will be anything other than an increased expectation of us at a time when schools are already at breaking point.“

The Association of Child Psychotherapists (ACP) has criticised the proposed changes for being “inadequate” and “based on false assumptions”, saying that making CAHMS responsible for supervising mental health support teams in school would take staff attention away from the children who need it the most.

Systemic problems remain

The ACP’s chief executive, Dr Nick Wagget, warned that children with the most serious and complex mental health problems could be harmed by the proposed changes. “We are concerned that, in many parts of the country, there has been a recent reduction in the quality of specialist NHS mental health services and this is not being addressed by the proposals in the green paper,” he said.

In December, ACP, the British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy, the British Psychoanalytic Council, and the UK Council for Psychotherapy released a survey showing the decline in children’s mental health services. Eighty-four per cent of mental health professionals surveyed said that children now can’t get help unless their illness is severe enough, meaning that children have to wait for their mental health to deteriorate sufficiently before they can see someone about it.

Across the country, waiting times have increased and services are being downsized or closing. The green paper would place yet more demands on a service that already struggles to cope with its current caseload. In November, the Bristol Post reported that 43% of children referred to the Avon and Wiltshire Mental Health Partnership in 2016/17 had their referral rejected, though the partnership insisted that children weren’t turned away and that cases that were not taken on by CAMHS were signposted elsewhere, such as face-to-face and online counselling.

“There’s a huge amount of children needing support and they need additional services, not alternative services. You can’t take it away from one place and put it in another,” said Dr Tessa Weir-Jeffery, child and adolescent psychotherapist and clinical service manager of the Bridge Foundation. She worked in CAMHS for 15 years and says that Bristol’s mental health services need investment, not just more demands.

“The green paper perpetuates the idea – unique to mental health – that you can treat your way out of a public health crisis”

“The workforce in CAMHS is wholly inadequate for the numbers of children needing support,” she said.

“If schools are going to become the front line in mental health we really need really well trained staff. I’m really concerned that there could be non-qualified staff potentially identifying mental health difficulties in schools.”

Missing the wider picture?

Simon Newitt, CEO at young people’s mental health project Off the Record Bristol, further commented that the proposed changes don’t address the “wider drivers of this current wave of distress, which remain embedded in our social, cultural and economic life”.

“The green paper is well intentioned, but it still fundamentally places ‘the problem’ inside the heads of young people,” he added.

“As a result, the green paper perpetuates the idea – unique to mental health – that you can treat your way out of a public health crisis. Insofar as having an impact on young people’s mental health and wellbeing, you wonder whether the proposed funding might not be better spent on recruiting more teachers and reducing class sizes.”

Keep the Lights On

Investigative journalism strengthens democracy – it’s a necessity, not a luxury.

The Cable is Bristol’s independent, investigative newsroom. Owned and steered by more than 2,600 members, we produce award-winning journalism that digs deep into what’s happening in Bristol.

We are on a mission to become sustainable – will you help us get there?

Join now

What makes us different?

Comments

Post a comment

Mark if this comment is from the author of the article

By posting a comment you agree to our Comment Policy.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related content

Meet the Bristol author helping women write their way through early motherhood

Juggling early motherhood with a writing career can be challenging. Bristol author Emylia Hall, founder of Mothership, has helped hundreds of creative mums thrive.

Listen: Bristol Unpacked with barrister Lucy Reed, on opening the secretive family courts to scrutiny

The family courts, which make orders for children to be taken into care, have long been a hidden world, but that's now changing. Neil talks to barrister and transparency campaigner Lucy about why this matters, and how the system needs to change.

Project helping new dads cope with parenthood faces uncertain future

Dad Matters, set up in 2024, has been supporting men across Bristol to navigate the tricky challenges of early fatherhood – but the council is now working out if it can continue funding the service.

Editorial: Why the Cable will be shining a light on child imprisonment

The Cable's investigations lead introduces our new long-term reporting strategy that puts impact at its heart – starting with a deep-dive on child prisons and exclusion from society.

South Bristol’s new youth centre is technically in Knowle West. Can it deliver for kids from Hartcliffe too?

A huge Youth Zone, part of a national network, will be opening in 2026 by the Imperial Retail Park. But is it what this side of the city needs? And will young people feel welcome, no matter what postcode they live in?

Listen: Bristol Unpacked with Samira Musse on community power, how to consult with people, and giving kids confidence lessons

What do the powers-that-be get wrong when they come to talk to communities – and how could this be done better? And why are youth services so crucial?

Join our newsletter

Get the essential stories you won’t find anywhere else

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter to get our weekly round-up direct to your inbox every Saturday

Join our newsletter

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter

Get our latest stories & essential Bristol news
sent to your inbox every Saturday morning