Bristol’s home of in-depth journalism
Powered by 2,600 members
The Bristol Cable

Delay in clean air action is defended by Labour despite criticisms, opposition parties put forward alternative proposals.

Mayor Marvin Rees used his speech to the Full Council in the Budget 19/20 session today to defend his actions regarding the Clean Air Plan, after missing the government-set deadline of 21 February to submit the plan to government.

Opposition parties used amendments to the budget to propose alternative strategies for improving Bristol’s air and reducing traffic on the roads.




The mayor wrote to the under secretary of state for environment Therese Coffey MP last week to explain his failure to meet the deadline, which had been extended from December, and which prompted Dr Coffey to say she was “absolutely astonished at your delay in improving air quality for the people of Bristol as quickly as possible”.

Rees wrote that he was “committed” to improving Bristol’s illegal and dangerous air

The mayor said a Clean Air Plan would be ready by March and would be “based on evidence”

quality, which contributes to 300 early deaths in the city annually.

He said the modelling that had been done on previously proposed measures to improve air quality showed “would produce significant adverse impacts on low income groups, compounding the challenges we face tackling equality and economic exclusion.” He continued, “We also received warnings that the measures could undermine our economic strength.”

The Clean Air Plan, the mayor said, would be ready by March and would be “based on evidence”.

Pressure from opposition, but motions fail

However, opposition parties used amendments to the budget to push for action on reducing traffic and improving public transport.

The most dramatic was the Green Party motion to amend the budget to include a new congestion charge on vehicles coming into Bristol from outside of the city, which would raise revenue to improve the city’s bus system.

Rees trashed the amendment in his opening statement. He said the proposal was not just “mistaken and seriously flawed” but would be “illegal”. The amendment, Rees said, was an example of addressing climate change through the “prism of privilege”.

Presenting the amendment later in the meeting, Cllr Jerome Thomas disputed the claim that such a charge on out of town drivers only would be ‘illegal’. He argued that “quick, clean and cheap buses must form the backbone” of addressing Bristol’s traffic problems, and described the move as a “bold and vital step”.

However Labour councillor for Lawrence Hill, Hibaq Jama, strongly disputed the legality of the proposal, and claimed it would amount to racism to implement it, based on the areas that would or would not be subject to charging. The motion was voted down.

The Liberal Democrats also put forward motions to fund transport changes including a bus card for under-25s in Bristol to encourage travel by bus. These motions were too voted down.

In summing up the Greens’ view of the budget, Thomas pointed out that, among many other reasons, the group could not back the budget because it included “no budget or plan for improving Bristol’s air to make it legal”.

The budget passed with amendments.

Support the journalism Bristol needs.

Our journalists have spent hundreds of hours covering Bristol’s local elections, but what comes after the votes have been counted is just as important. The debate about issues should continue, and decisions scrutinised. We’ll be here to report on that too. But only with your support. Become a member and support us in holding power to account in the city.

Join the Cable

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Local Elections 2021 Features

Greens and Labour are close in Windmill Hill, where climate, air pollution and housing are key concerns for locals

Local Elections 2021 Features

Will Bristol’s new clean air zone influence city centre voters at the polls?

Features Local Elections 2021

‘If everything worked you could get rid of cars’: Travel is the election issue in Bishopston and Ashley Down

Features Local Elections 2021

In Southville, a U-turn on parking problems is shaking up the local election race

Local Elections 2021 Fight For Fair Air Opinion

‘The new Bristol and WECA mayors will need to move fast to clean up Bristol’s air’

Bristol And The Climate Crisis Interviews Edition 24

The campaigners creating an environmental movement with social justice at its core

Join our newsletter

Get the essential stories you won’t find anywhere else

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter to get our weekly round-up direct to your inbox every Saturday

Join our newsletter

Get the essential stories you won’t find anywhere else

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter to get our weekly round-up direct to your inbox every Saturday