The Bristol Cable

Nick Dowson profile picture

Tiny homes are popping up in Bristol, with the council even bypassing its own policy to permit miniature flats. But as a solution to the housing crisis, this approach could do more harm than good.

Illustration: Laurence Ware

Tiny homes are big news. One of the first ideas that has floated to the surface from Bristol’s ‘housing festival’, which aims to showcase creative responses to the housing crisis, is allowing some homes to be built below minimum space guidelines.

A few months ago councillors also ignored their own policies and officer advice to approve plans for a Hillfields house and garden to be turned into three mini one-bed flats.

Meanwhile, charity Helping Bristol’s Homeless is – as is happening elsewhere in the world – converting shipping containers into temporary accomodation for homeless people, with help from local businesses.

“Everyone should have the option of decent housing”

Shipping containers can be turned into high-quality buildings. If they have been insulated and cladded, windows added, they can be highly efficient while avoiding looking and feeling like metal boxes – even if they remain firmly cuboid.

But are ideas such as these really an answer to our desperate shortage of high quality affordable housing? While new technologies and techniques enable new housing designs – and living spaces that require very little energy inputs, important in the struggle against climate change – this misses the big picture.

Human warehousing

The idea of cutting back on space to house people feeds into a pernicious idea that those with less money should be warehoused away. It erodes the idea of decent minimum standards for everyone; that everyone should have the option of decent housing.

The national space standard – which is up to councils to apply – recommends 37 square metres for a one-person, one-bedroom flat, or 50 square metres for two people. The UK already has some of the smallest homes in Europe. We don’t need smaller homes: we need ambitious social housing projects coupled with proper action to bring unused housing and land back into use.

You buy in

So we can't sell out

Become a member

Join the Cable
Rents are skyrocketing, and homelessness remains high: 2017 figures showed 966 people made applications for help in Bristol over 12 months, and this is only a proportion of those affected. Benefit changes and other social causes are often at the root. Universal credit, which began being rolled out for all new claimants in Bristol last year, has seen many people falling into rent arrears, risking a new wave of evictions.

At the same time homes stand empty. Recent precise figures are not available but 2015 research by the Cable showed at least 892 homes had been unused for over six months. Meanwhile developers sit on sites for years – or pitch new homes at the luxury market. Problems, in short, are economic and political, not based on design.

New forms of miniature housing – such as miniscule new the’pods’ for homeless people in Newport – should not be used as a top down solution without consideration of their possible impact on those who end up living within them.

Mental health impact

Some people forced to live in cramped spaces have reported their mental health taking a turn for the worse. Anxiety is fuelled in airless environments. And where couples sharing small apartments have no room for anything except enforced proximity, relationships may come under strain.

More broadly, social isolation can be fostered where people are embarrassed – or physically unable – to invite anyone round for a meal or even a cuppa. And what if a resident later wants a new partner to move in with them, or needs a carer? Shirking standards can create work later for council housing departments if they have to allocate new accommodation due to changed needs.

And while heating demands are likely to be lowered in smaller buildings, there could be other indirect negative impacts: if a lack of kitchen facilities means greater reliance on ready meals, or a ‘one-in-one-out’ attitude leads to throwing more things away.

For multi-bed homes, there is even some evidence that undersized ones may end up under-occupied – stingily-proportioned bedrooms being used as storage instead – meaning that rather than saving on land and resources, they do the opposite.

Container homes, or other easily moveable buildings, may be a useful stopgap while proper schemes of social housing are built. But miniature homes are no substitute for proper policy.

For those who choose ‘tiny homes’ as a way of life, they can be creative projects, inspirational, even beautiful. But forcing people into them shouldn’t be seen as a solution to the housing crisis – it’s just an ‘innovative’ way of getting people to accept less.

Nick Dowson is a freelance journalist who has written for the New Internationalist, the Guardian, the Independent, Moscow Times and Red Pepper.

Join 2,600+ Cable members working together to redefine local media.

Your support will help the Cable grow, deepening our connections in the city and investigating the issues that matter most in our communities.

Join now

What makes us different?


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related content

St James Priory: 900 years of refuge and healing

A residential rehab was once hidden in the busy Haymarket. But the last decade of funding cuts has meant it disappeared, like so many others.

‘Tents and shipping containers won’t solve our homelessness crisis. Here’s what will’

Former council lead for housing, Paul Smith shares his take on what Bristol needs to do about homelessness.

Charities scramble to find homes for 60 homeless people cut loose from Everyone In scheme

Bristol City Council carried on support for Bristol’s homeless during the pandemic, long after the government withdrew funding, but now it’s coming to an end and charities are struggling to plug the gap.

Number of homeless single people more than triples during pandemic

While rough sleeping has plummeted in the past 12 months, there has been a sharp increase in the number of people living in temporary accommodation.

Lockdown gave a safety net for Bristol’s hidden homeless... But many remain on the street this time round

Bristol's response to the Everyone In scheme offered a lifeline to people with no recourse to public funds (NRPF), but those who have become homeless since the first lockdown haven't had the safety net this time around, despite calls from homelessness charities to provide for rough sleepers.

Council forced to find alternative for rough sleepers as government scraps scheme

Homeless people in Bristol will be moved out of hotels, where they’d been placed to self-isolate, and into whatever housing the council can lay its...

Join our newsletter

Get the essential stories you won’t find anywhere else

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter to get our weekly round-up direct to your inbox every Saturday

Join our newsletter

Get the essential stories you won’t find anywhere else

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter to get our weekly round-up direct to your inbox every Saturday