Help us keep the lights on Support us
The Bristol Cable

Developer withdraws planning proposals for ‘grim’ and ‘Stalinist’ St Pauls flats

City

Controversial plans for a four-storey block of flats in St Pauls have been withdrawn.

The boss of developers Clayewater Homes says they spent “a lot of time, money and wasted energy” on the proposals for 28 homes, including 40% classed as affordable, at Lower Ashley Road and that if Bristol did not want them, they would take them elsewhere.

City councillors had said they were minded to refuse planning permission against officers’ advice and branded the proposed building “grim” and “Stalinist” at a development control committee meeting last month.

Members said the air quality at the site was so bad families should not live there and the plans would make it even worse.

The proposals were due to come back to committee on Wednesday, July 22, with officers’ suggestions of reasons for refusal but head of development Gary Collins said they had been pulled.

He told the remote meeting: “Because they have been withdrawn by the applicant, the application no longer exists and there is no right of appeal.

“So the matter has been dealt with in terms of that application and we will await any follow-up application which would come to committee as well.”

But speaking after the meeting, Devon-based Clayewater Homes managing director Brian Webber said they were abandoning the plans.

He said: “We spent a lot of time and money and a complete waste of energy to provide social housing for Bristol, and if they don’t want them, we will move on to the next one.

“We will cut our losses and get out of it because it will just keep dragging.

“We could have pushed hard because technically they could not refuse on grounds of air quality but you can’t win every fight and it has got to the point where it’s not worth the hassle.

“We are a social housing developer and this scheme was ideal for that.

“We have done four schemes in a row in Bristol and provided more than 80 units for affordable housing.”

Councillors were told at the June committee meeting 375 objections were received, mostly from campaigners trying to save three protected maple trees.

But members heard they were doomed anyway because of existing planning permission from 2019 for student houses and mixed use that would have seen them felled.

“The next developer needs to work with the local community and find a way of retaining these important trees”

Bristol City Council’s air quality team also objected to the proposals, along with Montpelier Conservation Group, Bristol Civic Society and Bristol Tree Forum.

Ashley ward Cllr Mike Davies spoke in support because of the affordable housing, but the committee agreed unanimously to ask officers to come back with a report outlining reasons for refusal.

The site at 31-45 Lower Ashley Road has a partially demolished office building and was used most recently as a hand car wash.

Speaking after the plans were withdrawn, Vassili Papastavrou, of Bristol Tree Forum, said: “The next developer needs to work with the local community and find a way of retaining these important trees.

“The trees are an asset. Keeping them would result in much better quality housing.”

Keep the Lights On

Investigative journalism strengthens democracy – it’s a necessity, not a luxury.

The Cable is Bristol’s independent, investigative newsroom. Owned and steered by more than 2,600 members, we produce award-winning journalism that digs deep into what’s happening in Bristol.

We are on a mission to become sustainable – will you help us get there?

Join now

What makes us different?

Comments

Report a comment. Comments are moderated according to our Comment Policy.

Post a comment

Mark if this comment is from the author of the article

By posting a comment you agree to our Comment Policy.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related content

Celebrating 30 years of the Base for Anarchy and Solidarity in Easton (BASE)

As the Easton-based social centre reaches its thirtieth birthday, we explore the history of the much-loved volunteer-run community space, which began life as a squat back in the mid-1990s

How a 19th-century journalist revealed the extent of poverty in Victorian Bristol

A series of newspaper articles published in 1883 give us a fascinating insight into working-class Bristolian life at a time of severe economic depression. It was the first real instance of investigative reporting in the city.

As Bristol battles to build affordable housing, developers are still gaming the system

The Cable has uncovered a brazen attempt by prolific property developers to escape building affordable housing, at a time when the city is still falling well short of its own targets.

‘South Bristol loses again’: new race to save athletics track

The former Whitchurch Athletics Track risks being bulldozed to make way for a planned housing development. Can local campaigners save it?

Listen: Bristol Unpacked, with former Lord Mayor Paul Goggin on homelessness, mental health and the struggle for south Bristol votes

'It's been eventful', says Paul Goggin, of a life that has featured both rough sleeping and local politics. He joins Neil Maggs to talk housing, faith, and whether Labour should fear Reform in wards like Hartcliffe and Withywood.

Listen: Bristol Unpacked with Amanda Sharman on leading the charge for boat-dwellers’ rights

Who are the boat-dwellers living around Bristol's harbour, and why have they been at loggerheads with Bristol City Council? Neil Maggs chats to Bristol Boaters' Community Association co-chair Amanda Sharman to find out.

Join our newsletter

Get the essential stories you won’t find anywhere else

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter to get our weekly round-up direct to your inbox every Saturday

Join our newsletter

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter

Get our latest stories & essential Bristol news
sent to your inbox every Saturday morning