Help us to Keep The Lights On for another decade! Back the Cable
The Bristol Cable

‘Why we must challenge media narratives of Travellers’

A Cable member recently cancelled their membership because we write about inequalities faced by Gypsies, Roma and Travellers instead of where the latest unauthorised encampment is. Here’s why we do that.

Moving on: Bristol's Gypsy, Roma and Traveller communities

Illustration: Liane Aviram

A Cable member recently cancelled their membership, saying that our articles are too pro-Traveller and refuse to acknowledge “that there are negative consequences from Travellers”. I decided to take this as an opportunity to explain why I choose to buck the trend in my series on Gypsy, Roma and Traveller communities. Why, instead of reporting on unauthorised encampments, pinpointing each new one and quoting appalled locals, I look at some of the issues often faced by these communities. 

Given that most of the time papers only write about Gypsies or Travellers when there’s an unauthorised encampment, or a crime has been committed, or to caricature them in reality TV, it’s not really that surprising these are the only things that come to some people’s mind when they see ‘Traveller’ in a headline. 

After decades of being caricatured, criminalised and romanticised by the media, it’s no wonder that racism against Gypsies, Roma and Traveller is so normalised. And this racism is perpetuated by the press, MPs (and not just Tories) and even well known celebrities – like when Orlando Bloom repeatedly called himself “just a p*key from Kent” during a Radio 1 interview and Catherine Tate’s character said it in a Comic Relief sketch with Tony Blair.

After decades of being caricatured, criminalised and romanticised by the media, it’s no wonder that racism against Gypsies, Roma and Traveller is so normalised.

Quite apart from the fact that people on unauthorised encampments make up a tiny minority of the Gypsy and Traveller populations, people aren’t driving onto your local playing fields for fun. Getting on a private site or getting planning permission on your own land is difficult when you’re a Traveller, and there’s a chronic shortage of council sites . And little appetite for building more.

Life for nomadic people has become harder over consecutive Tory governments, which have steadily chipped away at nomadic people’s right to travel, turning traditional stopping places into land for housing and bringing in increasingly hostile legislation. And local authorities have been slow to fulfil their duty to provide council sites. Whenever there’s a planning application for a new site, out come the placards and the objections and the site invariably doesn’t get built, or gets built right on the edge of town in a spot you probably wouldn’t want to live.

At this stage, it’s worth mentioning that I have pointed out, in several articles over the course of this series, the tensions unauthorised encampments can create, and included opinions from unhappy locals in bricks and mortar and interviews with Bristol councillors who want to bring in tougher legislation. I give more of a voice to them, in fact, than most papers give to the Travellers they write about. In a few I’ve written that a few Travellers go on unauthorised encampments, but that they’re in the minority. But, here’s a thing: you wouldn’t be expected to include caveats and qualifications like this about any other ethnic group.

Why the Cable writes ‘pro-Traveller’ articles

Instead of writing articles with dramatic headlines about crime, trespass and elaborate weddings, I have been focusing on different topics, that are underreported elsewhere in the media.

I’m not a cheerleader, though I do consider myself an ally. I’m a journalist, and responsible journalism involves delving deeper and looking into some of the causes behind the effects.

I do this for two reasons. Firstly, as press coverage of these communities is so overwhelmingly negative and has such a narrow focus, there is zero public interest needed to provide more of the same. There is plenty of that in other publications. GRT voices are hugely underrepresented in the media, and the voices of locals in bricks and mortar are hugely over-represented in these pieces generally. This series is a way of redressing the balance. 

There are so many articles about Travellers, but very few where the people being written about get to say anything. These populations are massively misserved by the media. How many articles have you read where an angry resident is interviewed about mess or noise or blocking the field? And how many of those articles included quotes from people on the encampments? 

And where, outside of the Travellers Times and occasionally in the Guardian, is the coverage of the chronic lack of sites, the huge health and education inequalities, racist profiling from the police? Where are the articles about hate crime these communities frequently endure, from verbal abuse and threats, to having caravans set alight – sometimes with families inside them? 

And secondly, one of the Cable’s editorial policies is to highlight injustices and give a voice to marginalised people, and these populations are among the most marginalised and socially deprived ethnicities in the UK. 

Our job and responsibility as journalists is to cover the under-reported voices, study the facts and context, and avoid shock headlines. It makes for a less sensationalised, exciting story, but a more accurate, balanced one. At the Cable, we distance ourselves from sensational journalism. This is what the other papers should be doing. If there was more responsible journalism about these populations, people wouldn’t have such a skewed narrative about Gypsies, Roma and Travellers. 

Join 2,500 Cable members redefining local media

Your support will help the Cable grow, deepening our connections in the city and investigating the issues that matter most in our communities.

Join now

What makes us different?

Comments

Report a comment. Comments are moderated according to our Comment Policy.

  • Thank you Hannah – you have my full support. – H

    Reply

  • Thanks Hannah – you have my full support. – H

    Reply

  • Best wishes to The Cable in its reporting on Traveller issues.

    Reply

  • Well done Hannah!

    Reply

  • Thank you Hannah for your balanced view, as a Traveller myself it’s hugely appreciated

    Reply

  • A sigh of relief to read. I’m apalled that someone cancelled their subscription because you refuse to resort to petty racism towards travellers.

    The reason why racism towards travellers goes on to be supported and encouraged by media, the government and pretty much all platforms, is because the travellers represent life outside of a system which is intent on sucking the most vulnerable dry.

    They don’t want us to look at travellers and get ideas. Then who would pay £1250 rent for a 2 bedroom property while struggling to buy food for their children?

    Reply

  • I have lived afloat on a sailing boat for the last 35 yrs,I have and continue to receive anti comments and behaviour from all walks of life ( Harbour masters, residents, businesses, sailing academies) I was once told when applying for a mooring that “We don’t have them” as tho I was some sort of scum. Things have not changed over the last 35 yrs we are still seen as second class citizens . SAD

    Reply

  • Great article and on the button.

    Reply

  • Good on you people.and very true,not once have I ever been.asked or.seen media ask the story or side n.reson of travelling folk as for.the reality tv side a things ,thats as fake.n.prepped.n propped as the rest the rubbish they drip feed the masses to keep them misinformed enough they think they are in loop and angry and scared enough to do as they want n need of them.strange strange times we are living in

    Reply

  • I’m new to this page but certainly not the topics being an Irish traveler it that’s Hannah fare play to you this racism has being going on too long to be left and not properly addressed we all bleed the same we all have feelings so I think that’s called being human isn’t it so why all the hatred and disrespect towards all Wallis of life I hope this ends soon there’s only 1 man that has the full right to judge us and that god himself so people think what way they threat people here won’t effect their place in heaven god made people not races to hate each other no man himself did that

    Reply

  • Absolutely agree – wonderful to read a balanced thoughtful article about Travellers for once

    Reply

Post a comment

Mark if this comment is from the author of the article

By posting a comment you agree to our Comment Policy.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related content

VIDEO: Chief constable challenged on ‘anti-racist policing’ progress and stop and search reform

It’s been a year since Avon and Somerset’s chief constable Sarah Crew admitted her service was institutionally racist, but what is she actually doing about it?

How St Paul’s residents fought to make the Malcolm X Centre a space for the community

The Malcolm X Centre on Ashley Road is one of Bristol’s most well-known and treasured community venues. What’s less well remembered is the struggle local people went through to lay the foundations for that status.

Listen: The Debrief, digging deeper into revelations of institutional racism at a local NHS trust

Priyanka Raval discusses the inside story of her recent investigation into racism in health services, and what it says about the state of the NHS, with Cable colleague Matty Edwards.

Whistleblowers reveal institutional racism at local NHS trust

A Cable investigation spanning months has uncovered that complaints of institutional racism at University Hospitals Bristol and Weston NHS Trust went unheard, despite promises from management to tackle the issue.

Listen: Cable Live, with Gary Younge talking journalism, race and power

Join the renowned writer, broadcaster and academic for a powerful talk exploring his childhood, journalism career, and how his experiences have shaped his work.

Listen: Bristol Unpacked with Ruth Pitter on the role of the charity sector, pioneering Black theatre and her recent MBE

Neil chats to Ruth, a daughter of the Windrush generation, on her decades of work with Bristol's voluntary and community groups, how that's changed as public services have been cut – and whether she feels conflicted about receiving an honour associated with empire.

Join our newsletter

Get the essential stories you won’t find anywhere else

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter to get our weekly round-up direct to your inbox every Saturday

Join our newsletter

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter

Get our latest stories & essential Bristol news
sent to your inbox every Saturday morning