We need your support to continue! Become a member
The Bristol Cable

Black and ethnic minority people more likely to face cannabis prosecution in Bristol, data shows

‘No excuse’ for ethnic disparities say police, as overall prosecutions for Class B drug rise despite local diversion programme

Black History Month

Black and ethnic minority people in the Bristol area are disproportionately likely to be prosecuted for possessing cannabis, analysis by the Cable has found.

People belonging to Black, Asian and minority ethnic (BAME) groups made up a fifth of those facing legal action for possession of the Class B drug within the Avon & Somerset Police (ASP) area in 2019, according to government data, while comprising only 7% of the population.

A senior local police officer, Chief Inspector Mark Runacres, told the Cable ASP had no excuses for the disparity and was working to understand and address it. He acknowledged that a small number of officers may be acting inappropriately based on discriminatory views, adding that such individuals were “not welcome” within ASP.

Overall, prosecutions for cannabis possession have also increased in the force area since 2016, despite ASP rolling out a scheme, lauded by campaigners and drug policy experts, to divert drug users away from the criminal justice system.

Court records examined by the Cable revealed some teenagers and adults are still being arrested and hauled before magistrates on single counts for possessing small amounts – in some cases just fractions of a gram – of cannabis. 

‘Proven to help individuals and reduce crime’

ASP’s Drug Education Programme (DEP) was adopted across the whole force last year, after being successfully piloted in Bristol from 2016. 

Rather than being prosecuted, people caught carrying personal amounts of drugs are offered a place on the diversion scheme. Between March and September 2020, 743 avoided a criminal record or jail time by attending the DEP, an increase of 173 in the same period the previous year. 

Drug users accessing the DEP attend an educational workshop run by a local drug service, which if completed spares them prosecution. Anyone can be offered a place on the innovative scheme – regardless of their past criminal record – but they only get one chance to attend. 

Initial findings showed that participants were less likely to reoffend than others who had gone through the criminal justice system, and that there were significant savings in police time and improved community and police relations. 

A spokesperson for the Transform Drug Policy Foundation told the Cable the charity is “fully supportive” of diversion schemes such as the DEP. 

“[They] move people caught in possession of drugs away from the criminal justice system and towards education and support,” the spokesperson said.

“This has been proven to help individuals, reduce crime and save money, and is now being copied by other police forces.” 

‘No excuses for disproportionality’

But although fewer people are being taken to court than earlier in the decade, and more people are participating in the DEP, Black and minority ethnic people are still disproportionately represented in prosecutions for cannabis possession in the Bristol area. In all, 19% of the 340 people brought before the courts in 2019 for personal cannabis possession were from BAME communities. 

And although all ethnic groups have experienced reductions in the absolute number of stop-and-searches, Black people are still disproportionately affected by these encounters. Over a fifth of stop-and-searches by ASP in July to September 2020 were of BAME people, the latest police data shows.

The numbers reflect a national picture in which one in five of those found guilty of cannabis possession in England and Wales last year were Black, according to official figures. There are serious ongoing ethnic disparities in how drug laws are enforced.

“These disproportionate numbers represent wasted lives, a source of anger and mistrust and a significant cost to the taxpayer,”  wrote David Lammy MP, chair of the 2017 review into BAME individuals’ experience of the criminal justice system. A range of responses and central government resourcing is clearly required.

Speaking to the Cable, ASP’s Chief Inspector Mark Runacres admitted there was more work to be done to confront racism in his force. 

“I’m not going to look to make up any excuses for that disproportionality [in the figures], because it’s something we [ASP] accept and we are working hard to try to understand so we can take steps to reduce it where it exists,” he said.

“As with any large organisation, I’m sure there will be officers who hold discriminatory views, a very, very small number who act on that inappropriately,” Runacres added. “People who hold those views and express them are not welcome in our organisation and are dealt with robustly to remove them, because they have no place in policing.”

Drug and knife crime crackdown

Addressing the overall increase in cannabis prosecutions, Runacres added: “There have been a number of factors that will have certainly fed into those fluctuations, and peaks and troughs. 

“The amount of proactivity we deliver as an organisation is directly linked to the number of drug enforcement outcomes we deliver,” he said, with an increase in the last 18 months relating to Operation Remedy, a crackdown on burglary, drugs and knife crime.

Last year, Bristolians shouldered a council tax hike to pay for 100 more police officers around the city – the first time in a decade ASP had increased its frontline staff – as part of that operation. With more officers on the streets came what Runacres, who leads the drug strategy for the force, calls “proactive policing” – targeted searches and arrests.

The uptick in cannabis prosecutions could also partly be explained by unintended search outcomes, the chief inspector said. “You’re looking for a knife but you find some cannabis…That can almost be a frustration to an officer because it’s a really low-level offence, it has not been the purpose of your search, but now another offence has been identified.”

Comments

    Report a comment
    Comments are moderated according to our Comment Policy

  • Till Bruckner says:

    That people are sometimes still arrested for fractions of a gram of cannabis in Bristol is a shocking waste of taxpayers’ money. Nobody should receive a criminal record and have their lives upended for committing a victimless “crime”.

    However, this article presents zero evidence that racism is at play here. BAME people might be overrepresented among those prosecuted, but this may (or may not) be because BAME people are more likely to use cannabis. For example, the same data presumably also show that males and people aged 20-30 are overrepresented, but this does not prove that policing in Bristol is sexist or ageist – it may or may not be, but such figures by themselves simply do not allow that conclusion.

    To prove racism, you would have to look at the stats in more depth and show that BAME people who got stopped and searched were less likely to carry illegal substances or items than white people getting stopped and searched (indicating racial profiling), or that arrested BAME people on average received tougher sentences for comparable offenses despite similar offending histories (indicating racial bias by the courts). I wouldn’t be surprised if either or both of those were true – but you need to analyse the stats properly to prove that.

    This entire article is built on a very simple statistical fallacy. The Bristol Cable really needs to up its editing standards. There is more than enough racism to go around in Bristol, the Cable wants to effectively challenge that, it has to start by getting its facts right.

  • Alon says:

    Hi Till,
    Thanks for the feedback. Always more digging to be done in this area, but limited available data can make that job difficult (for example accurately assessing drug use by ethnicity in Bristol/ the region).

    But here’s some more information in response to some of your points.

    The sentencing rates in the ASP force area for cannabis possession were marginally higher for black people vs white – 79% for white people and 81% for black people in 2019.

    Although stop and searches have fallen overall, those involving white people have fallen faster than those involving black people. In 2018/19, the stop and search rate for black people in Avon and Somerset was 18 per 1000 for black people vs 2 for white people according to gov data. (roughly 67% of stop and searches by the force were on the grounds of drugs)

    The positive outcome rate, when action is taken against people who’ve been stopped and searched – stood at 27.6% for white and 26.5% black people (in the last quarter).

    Elsewhere in the country, Metropolitan police data showed that Black and minority ethnic Londoners are more than twice as likely as whites to be arrested for simple possession of cannabis, despite government data from NHS Digital showing they use illicit drugs at roughly the same rate (from last year). From what I can see, ASP have not published their cannabis arrest/ ethnicity data recently.

    As ever, happy to continue this conversation, here or by email: alon@thebristolcable.org.

  • Till Bruckner says:

    Hi Alon,

    I really appreciate your thoughtful response. I think the positive outcome rate is a good metric. Note that the minor difference in that rate (27.6% vs 26.5%) doesn’t really justify the conclusion that Bristol police are being racist in this context.

    At first glance, the far higher stop and search rate (18 per 1000 for black people vs 2 for white people) combined with a similar positive outcome rate suggests that black people in Bristol are on average nine times more likely to be carrying drugs. However, that may be partially or completely due to the average age of black residents being lower, or other factors – without crunching the data, we simply do not know.

    The big problem here is that if you are black and have never broken the law, you are probably far more likely to get searched than if you are white and have never broken the law. (The same probably goes for male vs female and young vs old, regardless of skin colour.) That’s deeply hurtful to some of the innocent people getting stopped.

    Let’s hope Bristol police soon stop arresting people for victimless “crimes” altogether.

    Thanks again, and looking forward to your next story!

  • Till Bruckner says:

    The Guardian has a similar story today.

    Headline: “Young black males in London ’19 times more likely to be stopped and searched'”
    https://www.theguardian.com/law/2020/dec/03/young-black-males-in-london-19-times-more-likely-to-be-stopped-and-searched

    True. But look at the data table. If you are a white male aged 10-34 years old, you are *more* likely to be stopped than if you are a black male over 34 years old.

    Also, the text states that more than nine in ten stops are of males.

    The Guardian doesn’t state the positive outcome rate (sigh).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related content

Bristol still failing to shield young people from knife crime, police and council told

The fatal stabbing of 18-year-old Dontae Davis in Lawrence Hill sparked calls for more to be done to protect youngsters.

Listen: Bristol Unpacked on if Drill music is driving knife crime with youth worker Darren Alexander

In the wake of the tragic death of 18-year-old Dontae Davis in Lawrence Hill, what’s behind youth violence? And as Avon and Somerset Police have said recently, is drill music is a concern?

Tenth person jailed for involvement in Bristol Kill the Bill protest

Ryan Dwyer was arrested on warrant in Belfast last month in relation to his involvement in the Kill the Bill protest on 21 March.

Four more 'Kill the Bill' protesters plead not guilty to riot charge

The defendants could get lengthy jail terms if convicted when they stand trial in May and June next year in connection with the Kill the Bill protest on 21 March.

Exclusive: the witness who police didn’t interview after friend’s unsolved disappearance speaks for first time

Jo Hook had dinner with her friend Linda Millard the night before she vanished but was never interviewed by police as a witness. Linda’s disappearance is one of Avon and Somerset Constabulary’s longest running missing person cases, with a possible organised crime connection.

Community responses to latest wave of violent crime on Bristol to Bath cycle path

Local residents are getting organised to respond to protect the popular cycle route, as data obtained by the Cable shows violent incidents and thefts on the rise.

Join our newsletter

Get the essential stories you won’t find anywhere else

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter to get our weekly round-up direct to your inbox every Saturday

Join our newsletter

Get the essential stories you won’t find anywhere else

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter to get our weekly round-up direct to your inbox every Saturday