Last autumn, a key election pledge by the mayor on affordable homes bit the dust, making headlines. But what else do the numbers say about Rees’s record, and the council’s ongoing housing crisis headaches?
Last September, four months after a planned election could have already reinstated him if a pesky virus hadn’t put it on hold, a famous 2016 campaign-trail pledge by Bristol’s mayor Marvin Rees came to bite him on the arse.
A council committee report confirmed that in 2020-21, our local authority area would be getting nowhere near the 800 new affordable homes Rees promised to deliver annually by then. New figures reveal, in fact, that of the 1,350 to 1,994 homes that were completed each year in Bristol in the four years from 2016/17 to 2019/20, only between 188 and 312 each year were affordable.
Blaming the pandemic’s impact on construction, the document set a new “stretch target” of 500 affordable homes during 2020-21, which is likely to be “almost met” thanks to a forecasted 489 completions. In a deft bit of expectation management, it adds that house building targets are often influenced by a 20% “optimism bias” – meaning 389 affordable homes – below half of Rees’s target – is more realistic.
Still, the report goes on, a minimum of 797 more affordable homes should be added in 2021-22, and at least 1,028 in 2022-23. The council’s recently departed housing chief, Paul Smith, told the Cable’s Bristol Unpacked podcast in September the missed target should be seen as delay, not failure, given the state of 2020 and other non-Covid factors beyond the authority’s control.
Housing dominated Bristol’s last mayoral campaign – those pledges were important because the city’s affordability crisis took hold during George Ferguson’s tenure, with asking prices and rent levels spiralling. In April 2016, a Cable investigation revealed the council had flogged off hundreds of knackered but irreplaceable period homes, a practice that controversially continued under Ferguson, sparking anger just before the election.
Get our latest stories & essential Bristol news sent to your inbox every Saturday morning
Smith stopped that, with about 100 properties refurbished and put back into use as regular council homes or homeless accommodation, or handed over to specialist charities. This was possibly made easier because a plan developed by David Cameron’s government, which would have forced councils to sell their most valuable houses, was scrapped after Theresa May took over as prime minister.
Central government policy shackles councils’ ability to tackle local housing crises, and just before Christmas the House of Commons Public Accounts Committee described the national landscape of the last few years as a “deplorable… cycle of policy invention, abandonment and reinvention”.
Given that tough context, and with housing set to be just as hot an issue when the election rolls back round – mutant-coronavirus permitting – here we attempt a measured look at Rees-era progress and the challenges the next mayor, whoever they are, will face.
I am a former staff journalist, now freelance contributor to the Cable, reporting on housing and social affairs and supporting the media team with print, online and podcast production.
Investigative journalism strengthens democracy – it’s a necessity, not a luxury.
The Cable is Bristol’s independent, investigative newsroom. Owned and steered by more than 2,600 members, we produce award-winning journalism that digs deep into what’s happening in Bristol.
We are on a mission to become sustainable – will you help us get there?
The council should sell off some of its more expensive housing. A friend of mine is living around the downs and his council house is worth over £500k. This could be sold a two houses bought else where
Marvin Rees should be out of office as he’s had his time and has done nothing for Southmead and taken away open space in clen coo square and shutting off the shopping area and putting in flower beds which is a waste of money and time and this will be destroyed by the young ones who don’t give a dum.why don’t they build down at henbury as there is plenty of space behind the flats and Aldi plus he bury hill instead of wasting the statures in place here why not repair the roads around here which is in disrepair and the concrete badly breaking up
Bristol council paying huge sums of money to rent homes from banned landlord
Back in 2022, Bristol City Council obtained a five-year court order barring landlord Naomi Knapp from renting out her homes. Now, it’s spending hundreds of thousands of pounds of public money to use her properties as emergency accommodation.
Celebrating 30 years of the Base for Anarchy and Solidarity in Easton (BASE)
As the Easton-based social centre reaches its thirtieth birthday, we explore the history of the much-loved volunteer-run community space, which began life as a squat back in the mid-1990s
How a 19th-century journalist revealed the extent of poverty in Victorian Bristol
A series of newspaper articles published in 1883 give us a fascinating insight into working-class Bristolian life at a time of severe economic depression. It was the first real instance of investigative reporting in the city.
As Bristol battles to build affordable housing, developers are still gaming the system
The Cable has uncovered a brazen attempt by prolific property developers to escape building affordable housing, at a time when the city is still falling well short of its own targets.
Listen: Bristol Unpacked, with former Lord Mayor Paul Goggin on homelessness, mental health and the struggle for south Bristol votes
'It's been eventful', says Paul Goggin, of a life that has featured both rough sleeping and local politics. He joins Neil Maggs to talk housing, faith, and whether Labour should fear Reform in wards like Hartcliffe and Withywood.
Report a comment. Comments are moderated according to our Comment Policy.
The council should sell off some of its more expensive housing. A friend of mine is living around the downs and his council house is worth over £500k. This could be sold a two houses bought else where
Marvin Rees should be out of office as he’s had his time and has done nothing for Southmead and taken away open space in clen coo square and shutting off the shopping area and putting in flower beds which is a waste of money and time and this will be destroyed by the young ones who don’t give a dum.why don’t they build down at henbury as there is plenty of space behind the flats and Aldi plus he bury hill instead of wasting the statures in place here why not repair the roads around here which is in disrepair and the concrete badly breaking up