The Bristol Cable
Criticism of government’s handling of crisis reignites as the Care Quality Commission releases data on the number of Covid-related deaths at individual care homes. 

Nearly 300 care home residents died in Bristol with Covid-19 up to March this year, new data has revealed.

The figures, which show there were nearly 40,000 care home deaths in England, have been released amid the latest criticism of the government’s handling of the early months of the pandemic, and renewed calls for the promised reform of social care to happen as soon as possible.

The Care Quality Commission (CQC) released the data this week, which shows that 272 people died in Bristol care homes with suspected or confirmed Covid-19 up to 31 March 2021. However, these deaths only started to be recorded on 10 April 2020, so the true figure is likely to be higher.  

The highest death toll in a single care home was 20 in Hartcliffe Nursing Home. The other homes with the most deaths were Horfield Lodge (14), The Garden House, Granville Lodge, Amerind Grove Care Home, Frenchay Park Gardens Care Home and Glenview Nursing Home, all of which had 13. However, some of these homes are larger than others so will have more residents overall. 

Two care homes in the surrounding areas recorded even higher death tolls: Olive Tree House in Patchway, South Gloucestershire with 23 and Sycamore Lodge in Nailsea, North Somerset, with 21.

During the first wave of the pandemic, there was widespread media coverage about outbreaks in care homes, as well as concerns about availability of PPE and testing kits, overworked staff and residents being discharged back into homes from hospitals without a negative test. 

A Cable investigation found that during early outbreaks in April 2020, some care homes were struggling to access supply chains of PPE, residents were testing positive before care workers had been told to wear masks, and there was a shortage of testing for residents. The Cable also revealed that a Clifton care home Carlton Mansions lost around a third of residents during an outbreak. The data shows six deaths reported to the CQC.

‘Protective ring around care homes not a reality’

Labour frontbenchers have repeatedly accused Boris Johnson and the government of incompetence in the handling of the crisis. 

Last month, the Guardian learnt from some of the UK’s biggest care home operators that they repeatedly warned the Department of Health and Social Care and NHS England about the risk of not testing people discharged from hospitals into care homes in March 2020. 

It has also emerged that the now former health secretary Matt Hancock publicly promised to test all staff and residents in care homes last year, despite being told his deadline was impossible because of limited capacity by senior officials at meetings in April, May, and June.

Get our latest stories & essential Bristol news
sent to your inbox every Saturday morning

Hugh Alderwick, head of policy at the Health Foundation, said: “New data from CQC again show the grim toll that the pandemic has taken on people in care homes. 

“The scale of the impact of COVID-19 on social care was not inevitable. Central government support for social care during the pandemic was often too little, too late, particularly during the first wave. The government’s claim of ‘a protective ring’ around care homes was not grounded in reality,” he added.

“The social care system that entered the pandemic was underfunded, understaffed, and undervalued – scarred by decades of political neglect. These longstanding structural issues shaped the policy response to COVID-19 and effects of the pandemic on the system.

“The prime minister must deliver his commitment to reform adult social care in England and bring forward plans to do so this year. This reform must be comprehensive – not narrowly focused on preventing older people selling their homes to pay for care – including measures to improve staff pay and conditions and increase access to publicly funded social care.”

Read more

Delayed transparency

The figures show that nearly one in three of the care home deaths in Bristol have come in 2021, reflecting the deadly impact of the winter wave of infections. 

There were 902 deaths from all causes in care homes across Bristol during the whole period, according figures from the Office for National Statistics. This means that 30% of deaths are thought to be Covid-related. 

Across England, nearly 40,000 care home residents died with Covid during this period, which presents roughly one in three of all Covid deaths. The CQC stressed that many of the residents did not die or contract Covid-19 in a care home.

The CQC said it was now appropriate to publish these figures by individual care homes, because since the end of March deaths have “decreased substantially” and most care home residents have now been vaccinated. 

This comes after the regulator received criticism last year for not releasing data for individual homes. They was concerned this would “likely prejudice the commercial interests of care providers” and “risks creating confusion as to the prevalence, spread or impact of the virus”, according to information acquired by the Guardian via Freedom of Information.

Kate Terroni, the CQC’s chief inspector for adult social care, said: “In considering this data it is important to remember that every number represents a life lost – and families, friends and those who cared for them who are having to face the sadness and consequences of their death.

“We are grateful for the time that families who lost their loved ones during the pandemic have spent meeting with us and the personal experiences they have shared. These discussions have helped us shape our thinking around the highly sensitive issue of publishing information on the numbers of death notifications involving COVID-19 received from individual care homes.

A full breakdown of the number of Covid-realted deaths in all care homes in Bristol, as well of the rest of the country, can be found on the CQC’s data dashboard.

Comments

    Report a comment
    Comments are moderated according to our Comment Policy

  • George Moss says:

    The error also made were not treating our Elders because they used the End of Life (EOL)getting them to sign Illegal forms sometimes not even bothering to get form filled which meant did not try to treat them just left them to lose their lives this has been dismissed but it was done.All lives should be saved whatever your age.

  • Ex-worker for corporate (un)care sector says:

    Interesting report and investigation, does it seem, according to these stats that more poeple have died in care following the vacination roll out dec 2020-2021?

    Also, Its strange how it took the gov and the cqc (after a freedom of information request), so long to release information about deaths in care homes, despite their alleged independence. My experiece with CQC is that they often seem to be in cohorts with local authorities and gov to make inspections/investigations (due to complaint by whistleblowers) ineffective. Also any thoughts on manditory enforcements of vacinations/medical proceedures and the exclusion & cohersion of s/u and support workers and other workers around these sectors? I’ m hearing from buddies still in the sector there has been oppostion to company owers perminantly enforcing these and other measures across the sector, firing workers that have worked in the sector for many many yeas in some cases. I think we are entering a very slippery slope if politicians and the media start making people hate on each other due to these matters. I tend to feel. Wether vacinated or unvacinated we must not allow the any gov or company directors to divide us on these matters.

    • Adrian Dumont-Namin says:

      I agree with you. Freedom needs all of our voices. The government seems to be in line with the W.E.F. / Agenda 2030 . Are we seeing serious breeches to democracy and freedom ?

  • Adrian Dumont-Namin says:

    Before anything else, the government and authorities need to explain the ‘Do Not Recussitate’ Orders as well as the Nil By Mouth Orders given to elderly people in care homes.
    What we are seeing is dubious on many levels.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related content

Kingsdown Sports Centre threatened with closure

Jubilee Pool in Knowle faces the same fate, under a new proposed 'leisure investment strategy' from the council.

Long Covid and the frontline of mass unemployment

Over a million people are still unwell months after catching Covid-19. With sick pay quickly running out, thousands could lose their jobs and face financial ruin.

Swimming in Bristol Harbour is possible. How can we make it happen?

We talk to Julien De Smedt, the architect behind Copenhagen’s first and best-known swimming harbour bath, and Johnny Palmer, founder of local campaign group Swim Bristol Harbour, about what it takes to make a harbour swimmable.

‘The end of the mask mandate threatens Bristol’s young and vulnerable’

Masks coming off from ‘freedom day’ is going to restrict people’s movement around the city on Bristol’s buses.

Listen: Healthcare in Bristol before the NHS

This week I met with Dr Michael Whitfield to discuss Bristol's dispensaries. For the two hundred years or so before the creation of the NHS in 1948, the dispensaries were one of the main providers of healthcare in Britain, especially for its poorest people. We discussed how the dispensaries opera...

Southmead Hospital taking 'critically ill COVID patients' from as far away as Birmingham

Southmead Hospital faces 'challenge' as patient numbers hit a peak and surgeries and routine appointments are cancelled last month.

Join our newsletter

Get the essential stories you won’t find anywhere else

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter to get our weekly round-up direct to your inbox every Saturday

Join our newsletter

Get the essential stories you won’t find anywhere else

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter to get our weekly round-up direct to your inbox every Saturday