Help us keep the lights on Support us
The Bristol Cable

Barton Hill tower block residents’ lives turned upside down by emergency evacuation

Told to leave their homes under chaotic and confusing orders by Bristol City Council, tenants of Barton House face an uncertain future after their homes were deemed unsafe.

A photo of Barton House tower block

Photos: Alexander Turner

Reports

“I don’t know where we are going to go, I don’t know what’s happening,” says Yasmin, tearfully, standing confused at the foot of Barton House with her one-year-old son in her arms and his buggy at her feet. 

Her neighbour had only moments earlier knocked on her door and warned that she needed to leave the tower block immediately because it’s unsafe. She thought, in the moment, that it was about to collapse. 

“We rushed down with just nappies for [my son] and I don’t know what is happening,” the 30-year-old told the Cable at the time, at about 6pm on Tuesday evening, as an evacuation of the block was under way.

Bristol City Council, which owns and manages the building, had declared a major incident due to a “risk to the structure” of the tower, which is the oldest in the city – completed in the late 1950s.

A photo of residents of Barton House picking up their belongings
Kubra, a resident of Barton House, returns to the tower to collect more of her things on Wednesday afternoon (Alexander Turner)

About 400 people, roughly 100 of whom are children, were ordered to leave the building. Most did, but they left without knowing exactly what was going on, and without word on where they could stay.

And 24 hours later, many Barton House residents were waiting on a call back from the council about temporary accommodation while further assessments on the building were carried out.

The building’s construction, a survey this week revealed, is significantly different to its blueprints. There is a “material risk” to the structure of the block in the event of a fire, explosion or large impact, the council said.

The Cable has revealed that structural issues were uncovered at the tower block back in 2019, but the council said the issues reported this week were more serious.

The authority urged anyone who could stay with relatives or friends to do so. Some 57 hotel rooms were provided to people who needed them most, and four people stayed at a rest centre in City Hall.

Yasmin and her son were able to stay with a friend, but she says some of her neighbours slept in their cars and that some refused to leave the building. She says she had not yet been given temporary accommodation.

“I am waiting anxiously for a call, not knowing where I will be tonight or tomorrow,” she told the Cable.

She is just one of hundreds of people whose lives have abruptly and dramatically been turned upside down by the evacuation – with no information about when they are likely to be able to return to their homes.

The trauma of displacement

Hassan, a member of the community engagement team at the nearby Wellspring Settlement, spent much of Wednesday meeting with residents, offering support and information where he could. 

He paused for lunch in the centre’s cafe with Nuh, who was allocated temporary accommodation at a Holiday Inn in the city centre with his partner and two children, aged five and six. 

The 46-year-old and his family were taken to the hotel on one of three buses laid on for residents on Tuesday night. He said his children could not eat the hotel food and went to school without breakfast.

This morning, he and his wife returned to their flat in Barton House to cook and collect their remaining possessions. They are concerned about how living in the hotel will affect their children’s health.

“This is not a healthy situation,” Nuh told the Cable. “There is one room for the four of us, my daughter couldn’t sleep last night and we are all struggling a lot. It is not fair that this is happening.”

A photo of Barton House tower block
Barton House, which was built in the last 1950s, is Bristol’s oldest tower block. (Photo: Alexander Turner)

Hassan said that the council is working hard to offer temporary housing to displaced residents.

“It is a traumatic thing, and we need to do what we can to make sure people are safe,” he said, adding that there were people who live in the block refusing to leave their homes. 

“There are some people who do not want to come out, we are going to talk to them now and see what we can do,” he said. “We are doing our best to keep people informed and help them find somewhere to stay.”

Confusion and uncertainty 

Kubra arrived at the community centre alone on Wednesday afternoon with a bag full of her things. She told staff in the Wellspring’s cafe, where the lunchtime rush had just finished, that she needed help with accommodation.

The cafe staff called the council’s helpline set up for residents on her behalf and explained that she had a child with special educational needs and needed guidance from the support team in her native language of Urdu.

Judging by others’ experience, she could be waiting a while.

Sidra Riaz stayed with a friend overnight with her two daughters, aged three and six, and was waiting for a call back from the council about temporary accommodation.

“Yesterday I was picking up my daughter from school and a friend told me we could not go back to the building,” she told the Cable at the community centre. “I have all my stuff, clothes, at the house and I am scared to go back.

“I can stay with a friend for maybe one or two days but no longer, it’s very worrying that I cannot speak to anyone at the council about this.”

Sidra says she called the council’s helpline it set up for residents early Wednesday morning and staff told her they would contact her with information as soon as possible. She was still waiting on their call at 4pm.

Questions over council’s planning

Questions remain about why the council chose to act so suddenly, leaving even local councillors in the dark about initial, provisional plans for an evacuation. 

Yassin Muhamed, Green councillor for Lawrence Hill, says he was first told about the structural issues with the building on Tuesday afternoon by the council’s chief executive.

“But they knew on Monday that something was bad, so why it happened this way I don’t know,” he told Cable from the Wellspring settlement. “What happened in those 24 hours? There are lots of questions.”

A photo of tower block Barton House
Barton House is one of a number of high rises in this area to the east of central Bristol. (Photos: Alexander Turner)

Kye Dudd, the council’s cabinet member for housing services and energy, said the structural issues with the building lay with its concrete sections and that “it wasn’t built to the design specs”. 

He added that he had a briefing on Monday where a report from a structural engineer was given to him. “It looked really bad,” he told BBC Radio Bristol. “I said to the team we need to prepare for a potential emergency evacuation.

“But we also had to seek further advice from the fire brigade, so the following day we had another meeting… and we had some prep on where we would potentially move people… We had to take the decision with the information we had as the safety [of] residents is paramount.”

‘Everyone came together’

Amid the chaos and confusion following the evacuation, the local community came together to support those who were displaced.

A photo of Denise from Cafe Conscious in Barton Hill
Denise Dixon runs Cafe Conscious round the corner from Barton House. (Photo: Alexander Turner)

Deniece Dixon runs Cafe Conscious, which is a three minute walk from Barton House. She opened up the space for residents, offering them free food, hot drinks overnight, taking pressure off the community centre.

“My friend messaged me about what was going on and straight away I got down here,” she told the Cable from the cafe, donations of food, drinks, nappies and underwear piled around us.

“[Residents] were devastated,” she said. “I had people in here in tears today… told to grab her clothes and documents and leave, and they don’t know when they will be able to go back. Imagine!

A photo of Cafe Conscious in Barton Hill where supplies were donated for residents who had to leave their homes.
Cafe Conscious provided respite for residents. (Photo: Alexander Turner)

“But it’s amazing how the people of this area have come together,” she said. “We just opened up a safe space and said ‘let’s do this’, and everyone else did all the work.”

 The Cable has also launched a crowdfunder to help with supplies for the displaced residents, which at the time of writing had raised more than £3,000.

Left in the dark

Barton House residents have not been given any kind of timeframe for how long they will be without a permanent home, if they are ever able to return.

Bristol’s mayor Marvin Rees, in a blog post on Wednesday evening, wrote that it would take “some time” for further surveys to be carried out. He said residents would need to be away from home while they are completed.

“A number of issues have emerged that suggest the building’s construction is sufficiently different to its blueprints that there is a material risk to the structure of the block in the event of a fire, explosion or large impact,” the blog post read.

“We are working at pace to complete further surveys now, to go deep into the structure and understand when it would be safe for residents to move back into Barton House.”

Independent. Investigative. Indispensable.

Investigative journalism strengthens democracy – it’s a necessity, not a luxury.

The Cable is Bristol’s independent, investigative newsroom. Owned and steered by more than 2,500 members, we produce award-winning journalism that digs deep into what’s happening in Bristol.

We are on a mission to become sustainable, and to do that we need more members. Will you help us get there?

Join the Cable today

The Cable is currently raising money for the residents of Barton House. Find out more.

Keep the Lights On

Investigative journalism strengthens democracy – it’s a necessity, not a luxury.

The Cable is Bristol’s independent, investigative newsroom. Owned and steered by more than 2,600 members, we produce award-winning journalism that digs deep into what’s happening in Bristol.

We are on a mission to become sustainable – will you help us get there?

Join now

What makes us different?

Comments

Post a comment

Mark if this comment is from the author of the article

By posting a comment you agree to our Comment Policy.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related content

Council still thinking about knocking down Barton House, months after residents’ return

Sources said options for the Barton House high-rise are still being weighed up after a report was commissioned into its possible demolition

‘I can do action’: cafe owner who organised tower block evacuation response aiming to be councillor

When she heard Barton House was being evacuated in November, Cafe Conscious owner Deniece Dixon got to work helping families who had become homeless. Two months on, she explains why she’s set her sights on City Hall

Listen: Bristol Unpacked with ACORN’s Wesley Bear on activism, the Barton House evacuation, and frosty relations with the council

Relations between Bristol City Council and community union ACORN have become increasingly fractious, with recent clashes over council tax and the evacuation of a Barton Hill tower block. Neil asks Wesley why, and whether there's a way back.

Barton House evacuation: Was the chaos and confusion completely unnecessary?

With a lack of clear information from the council, rumours and speculation ruled as residents decanted from their homes were left in the dark about what was going on. Campaigners say the authorities could have planned this better.

Cable Live: Peter Apps talks Grenfell, buildings safety and where the housing crisis goes next

Journalist and author Peter Apps discusses the Grenfell inquiry, how the UK neglected its social housing, and what the future looks like.

Bristol raises £10k for Barton House residents in 48hrs

A Cable crowdfund to support the residents of Barton House is 1,200% funded - and counting.

Join our newsletter

Get the essential stories you won’t find anywhere else

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter to get our weekly round-up direct to your inbox every Saturday

Join our newsletter

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter

Get our latest stories & essential Bristol news
sent to your inbox every Saturday morning