Keep proper journalism alive. It's time to Back the Cable
The Bristol Cable

‘Speaking is a political act’: Bristol artists push Arnolfini for action over Palestine controversy

The prominent gallery has apologised for cancelling two events from the Palestine Film Festival in November – but an emerging artists-led campaign says it doesn’t go far enough.

A woman with a face covering sits behind a placard marked 'Free Palestine'
Features

“The core of the problem is that the Arnolfini have failed to uphold freedom of expression on Palestine… in a way that we felt was really concerning, and could set a dangerous precedent across the arts and charity sector.”

This is the view of singer, composer and sound artist Nik Rawlings, who has a particular interest in the human voice as a tool for exploring ideas about identity and community – and who is given permission to speak. This has become particularly resonant in relation to the ongoing war in Gaza, as Palestinians and their supporters try to raise awareness of what is happening.

“If you’re able to use your voice, it is your primary mode of communication beyond the non-verbal,” says Rawlings, who uses they/them pronouns. “So it is a deeply political act to speak.”

Rawlings joined hundreds of other artists in condemning Arnolfini’s decision in November to cancel two events from the Bristol Palestine Film Festival. The prominent Bristol gallery had justified the move by saying it “could not be confident that the event would not stray into political activity”.

Though the events themselves – including a screening of the film Farha by Jordanian-Palestinian director Darin J Sallam, and a poetry evening featuring hip hop artist and activist Lowkey – were later hosted by other venues, the decision sparked widespread condemnation and anger among Bristol’s artistic communities. 

Activists staged two peaceful sit-in protests in the Arnolfini’s foyer, in late November and December, demanding an explanation of the decision and accusing the gallery of complicity in genocide against the Palestinian people. 

“After those first couple of sit-ins, which were pretty successful in being visible and disruptive, we coalesced fairly organically around the artists that had attended and started to build a bit of a group around the campaign,” explains Rawlings. 

The Bristol artists – connected via a WhatsApp group that includes several hundred members – became affiliated with Artists for Palestine, a campaign group which was formed in 2015.

Artists for Palestine exists to “support the Palestinian struggle for freedom, justice and equality”, according to their website, and pledges to “accept neither professional invitations to Israel, nor funding, from any institutions linked to its government until it complies with international law and universal principles of human rights.”

‘Free space for debate and discussion’

At the time of writing, Bristol Artists for Palestine’s call for artists to disengage from the Arnolfini has attracted the support of over 1,200 signatories including writers Alice Oswald and Nikesh Shukla, and musicians such as Giant Swan and Massive Attack’s Robert Del Naja. 

Aside from an official statement and apology from Arnolfini, the group’s core demand is for the gallery to be a space where debate and discussion can freely take place. 

Rawlings says they are worried that Arnolfini’s “wilful misreading of the Charity Commission guidelines” around political activity risks setting a dangerous precedent across the arts and charity sector.

Rawlings mention the situation in Germany, which has been notable among European countries for its particularly harsh restrictions on Pro-Palestinian protests and crackdowns on artists and musicians expressing opposition to the Israeli bombardment of Gaza. 

Bristol Artists for Palestine is geared towards constructive conversations with the Arnolfini management, and hopes to enter into mediated discussions with the gallery’s board members. 

In January, Arnolfini apologised for the debacle via a statement on its website: “We wish to express our deep regret for the distress caused to those we consider allies.”

“We also fully acknowledge that the original communication regarding these programming changes was not clear enough, all of which we apologise for without reservation.”

But for Rawlings, this statement does not go nearly far enough. “Their statement says nothing about the decision-making. It addresses that there’s been some failure of governance, which is an understatement. But it says nothing about cancelling and censoring Palestinian voices during a genocide.”

Despite being deeply opposed to the Arnolifini’s decision, Rawlings stresses that the group’s campaign is aimed at the Arnolfini management, not the majority of the gallery’s staff. “They’re a major cultural employer in the city. We owe it to the staff members who had no part in making that decision not to put them at risk. They are stakeholders, they’re colleagues, they’re collaborators, they’re people we respect and like.”

Ultimately, the group hopes to be able to rebuild trust with the gallery. “It’s not good for any of us just to trash the Arnolfini. We have a vested interest in bringing them to the table and getting a good result, which for our signatories looks like a public statement addressing the decision, recommitting to freedom of expression with no exception on Palestine.”

The Arnolfini did not reply to our request for comment. 

Join 2,500 Cable members redefining local media

Your support will help the Cable grow, deepening our connections in the city and investigating the issues that matter most in our communities.

Join now

What makes us different?

Comments

Post a comment

Mark if this comment is from the author of the article

By posting a comment you agree to our Comment Policy.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related content

Listen: Bristol Unpacked with Salma Najjar on experiencing the Gaza war as a Palestinian in the UK

Salma, a lawyer who spent her childhood in Gaza, shares the 'dystopian' experience of life under occupation and knowing your family are in a war zone, as well as discussing happier memories and pro-Palestinian activism in the UK.

Listen: Inside Bristol’s ‘murder factory’ arms facility, with the activists on trial for occupying it

Palestine Action activists are on trial for smashing into an Elbit factory that ships weapons technologies to Israel. But at the heart of this case is the history and tragedy of Israel’s operations in Gaza, and how Bristol’s facility plays a role in the death and destruction.

Darin J Sallam on what shaped her creative life, her film Farha and the controversy it sparked from the Middle East to Bristol

Sallam’s film has been praised for its bravery in choosing to tackle the events of the Nakba – one of very few films to do so – but was also heavily criticised by Israeli authorities and prompted a boycott campaign

‘Silence is complicity’: director of landmark Palestinian film slams Arnolfini for cancelling screening

In a move that sparked outrage and protest, the Bristol gallery claimed hosting the showing of Farha would risk breaking charity rules on political activity.

75 years since the Israeli occupation, three Palestinian women speak out about their struggle

Back in March, the Cable met three women from Palestine who visited Bristol to talk about life in the occupied West Bank. Two months later, we catch up on the 75th anniversary of the Nakba.

Jews in Bristol protest Israel’s violence and oppression in Palestine

British Jews have gathered across the country to call for justice for Palestinians.

Join our newsletter

Get the essential stories you won’t find anywhere else

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter to get our weekly round-up direct to your inbox every Saturday

Join our newsletter

Subscribe to the Cable newsletter

Get our latest stories & essential Bristol news
sent to your inbox every Saturday morning